Wow. Just wow.
Firstly, since we normally refer to Makoto’s first anime as “Voices” and that’s the main word in this one, I’m going to use a different name to refer to this one, so I’m going to call it “Deep Below”. Now the translated name is a bit odd. “Hoshi” means star, “kodomo” children, and “ou” means “to chase”, so really, you would think the title should be translated to “Children who chase the stars”, but that’s not what it’s been translated to. I don’t know if Makoto-san is responsible for this or it’s a decision from his publisher. I’d prefer to think the latter, but to be honest it’s a beautiful name, and far more relevant to the story.
Makoto Shinkai has not released an anime in four years, and I’ve been simply dying for his next story. I used to be (and still am, to some extent) a huge Miyazaki fan for his amazing, creative and innocent stories of fantasies and far away worlds, but when Makoto released “Voices from a Distant Star” in 2002 after rendering the entire thing at home on his G4 iMac, my world changed. There was a new kami-sama of storytelling, who’s vision and attention to detail and AMAZING animation skills blew me away. Not to mention his passion for stories about loss and emotional distance. So when I first heard about Hoshi wo Ou Kodomo in around 2010, I waited with bated breath. I mean my heart ACHED for a new Makoto movie.
I downloaded it a couple of days ago (it’s not available to buy here yet, but you can be sure I will be first in line to purchase it) but I just wasn’t ready to watch it yet. I had to be prepared. All his other movies have just torn me limb from limb, emotionally speaking. Voices was just so heartbreaking. Places Promised was just so beautiful and moving, and 5cm Per Second ? Well. I think I must have cried for three days solid after seeing that, and no matter how many times I watch it, It always leaves me feeling agonised and sorrowful and like someone has just torn my still-beating heart out of my chest. So it was with a great deal of anticipation that I prepared to watch Deep Below.
I fired it up on my laptop, and less than 5 seconds in, I gasped at the stunning beauty. I immediately stopped it. This was a movie that did not deserve to be watched on a 13″ laptop screen. I needed to wait until morning and view it on my 50″ plasma. When I started it, I called my mum in and said “Have a look at this”. She watched the first scene where Asuna runs down the path and across the rail bridge which is nothing short of stunning. The way the shadow and the rays of light play across the scene and the way the sun glimmers across the water far below and beautiful clouds drift across the sky cannot fail to impress, and my mother was as moved as I was, referring to it as “incredible”.
This is a movie I won’t spoil for you at all, and in fact, I won’t even describe the plot, because you just don’t know what this story is about when it begins. There are no cliches in this movie. It is truly beautiful and original. I will say that is about two people; a girl and her school teacher, who set off for a journey to an underground world to bring back to life the people they have lost. A character later in the movie says “Everyone set out on their journey as a heartfelt cry for help”. It is a well-meaning story of loss and naievete. Earlier, Asuna says “This is not where I belong. There is a place I’ve never seen before”. You may think you know how it’s going to turn out, but you’re probably wrong.
It’s not that the story is surprising, it’s just that fails to adhere to the typical cliches you might expect such a movie to follow. But at the same time, it’s not hard to see a little bit of Nausicaa or Laputa, a little bit of Grave of the Fireflies, some Totoro and a healthy splash of Princess Mononoke in this movie. Not because Makoto is copying these movies, but because things such as spirits and demons, totem animals, and gods of life and death are common themes in Japanese storytelling.
One of the things that surprised me a little is that there is not a heart-wrenching scene that leaves you feeling hollow and lost at the end of this movie. It is not 5cm Per Second at all. It is a story of adventure and innocence, not a story of tradgey and sorrow. In fact, the ending is very happy and upbeat despite the fact that none of them find what they are looking for. This is a story you can happily show your children without fear of upsetting them, but of course at the same time, it is so beautiful and deep that noone could ever call it a mere children’s story. I did have tears in my eyes throughout the movie many times, but I am a very emotional person and sadness and happiness and love move me greatly. Ultimately, the story is very simple in theme. There are so many things you think could have happened, characters you think should have played a bigger part, but they don’t.
This story is beautiful, but uncomplicated. It’s deep, but it’s not a mind-fuck. It’s not surreal like Mononoke and thankfully it’s certainly not 5cm per second, even though it is still very much a story of letting go of the past. It’s still a story about distance and loss, but these themes are toned down and just serve as the characters’ motivation rather than some moral that’s being rammed down your throat. If anything, the story is more like Miyazaki’s Totoro than any of Makoto’s other works. It’s facile, elegant and touching. It’s sweet. Yes, I was expecting and even hoping for a heart-wrenching tear-jerker that almost made me give up on life, but I’m also glad that Makoto has not gone this way with Deep Below as it makes it more accessible for new fans and is a light and refreshing story to add to his library.
Deep Below will probably never be looked at the same way as Voices or 5cm, and bears far more similarities to Places Promised, which is a story about sadness and loss, but also a story about adventure and closure, and that is the same theme we find in Deep Below. It is definitely a story of innocence, adventure and closure, even though it still has Makoto written all over it. While the ending is good, it could so easily have wrapped everything up with a little bow in a Disney-like fashion and shown how they all go back to their lives happier, but it chooses not to. There is no journey home from the underworld. The story ends quite suddenly when the resolution is reached with just a brief look at Asuna returning to school and then the credits roll with just a couple of still pictures of simple moments during the film.
Was it what I was expecting ? No. Was it stunningly beautiful in terms of both animation and story ? Absolutely. This is essential Makoto, and canonical anime as far as I’m concerned and I truly hope I have the chance to see it at the cinema with someone I care about so that I can share the experience with them. I think it’s important to be warned that this movie is not like Voices or 5cm and if you go into it expecting it to be, you could be a little disappointed, but it is most definitely the single most stunningly beautiful anime (beating 5cm by a tiny margin) in visual terms that I have ever seen and has a cohesive, simple, but uniquely Japanese story. If I gave numerical ratings anime, you could be sure that Hoshi wo Ou Kodomo would receive my highest praise.




You love when I share random Asian music with you, don’t you ?
It was after 10pm at night. I’d been drinking cheap Vietnamese $3.50 brandy and cheap Vietnamese $1 wine this evening and chatting on irc. I’d eaten most of my snacks and I wanted something else. I didn’t want to go to CauXuang and get ostrich and I’d already been to my other favourite place once today for Singapore noodles and vegetables and I was bored of my regular pho cafe so I wanted something different.

